Fluid Capacity: A Jurisprudential Rereading of the Child’s Tamyiz (Discernment) in Light of Subjective Relativity and the Hadith of Raf’ al-Qalam (Lifting of the Pen)

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Fiqh and Usul, Al-Mustafa Online University, Qom, Iran

Abstract

Despite its fundamental role in determining the scope of an immature child’s legal capacity (ahliyyah), the concept of tamyiz (discernment) in Islamic jurisprudence has often been defined through rigid, age-based criteria—as if a child abruptly transitions from “non-discerning” (ghayr-mumayyiz) to “discerning” (mumayyiz) upon crossing a specific threshold (e.g., seven years of age). Criticizing this conventional approach, the present study defends a theory that can be termed “fluid capacity” (al-ahliyyah al-sayyalah). According to this theory, discernment is not realized at a fixed age but manifests as a gradual, highly subject-specific process; thus, discernment in matters of ritual prayer (salat) is not identical to that in transactions (bay’) or confession (iqrar). Relying on Quranic verses (particularly the verse of testing orphans, ibtila’ al-yatama), the noble Sunnah (including the narration of the “three seven-year periods” and the narration concerning child theft), and jurisprudential maxims (qawa’id fighiyyah), this paper demonstrates that, contrary to popular belief, the discerning child is neither absolutely under legal guardianship (mahjur) nor absolutely obligated (mukallaf). Rather, the child occupies a spectrum bounded by “absolute legal incapacity” on one end and “full legal obligation” on the other. Within this spectrum, the noble tradition of Raf’ al-Qalam (Lifting of the Pen) does not signify the absolute negation of legal capacity, but rather the negation of binding obligation and accountability for a child whose capacity is dynamically evolving and fluid in proportion to each specific subject matter. The methodology of this research is descriptive-analytical, employing a mixed-methods approach for data integration and jurisprudential inference.

Keywords

References

 قرآن کریم.
ایروانی، م.ب. (1426ق). دروس تمهیدیة فی القواعد الفقهیة. انتشارات فقه اسلامی.
جمعی از محققان. (1425ق). موسوعة أحکام الأطفال (چاپ اول). مرکز فقه الأئمة الأطهار (ع).
حر عاملی، م.ب.ح. (1413ق). وسائل الشیعة. انتشارات اسلامیه.
حلی، ح.ب.ی. (1424ق). تذکرة الفقهاء. انتشارات مرتضوی.
خمینی، ر. (1434ق). کتاب البیع. مؤسسه تنظیم و نشر آثار امام خمینی.
خوئی، ا.ق.م. (1417ق). مصباح الفقاهة فی المعاملات. انتشارات انصاریان.
 رازی، م.ب.ا.ب. (1420ق). مختار الصحاح. دارالکتاب العربی.
 راغب اصفهانی، ا.ق.ح.ب.م. (1412ق). المفردات فی غریب القرآن (چاپ اول).
 روحانی، م.ص. (1428ق). فقه الصادق (چاپ چهارم). منشورات الاجتهاد.
سعدی ابوجیب، س. (1408ق). القاموس الفقهی. دارالفکر.
سیستانی، س.ع.ح. (1424ق). منهاج الصالحین (چاپ نهم). دارالکتاب العربی.
صدوق، م.ب.ع. (1404ق). من لا یحضره الفقیه. دفتر انتشارات اسلامی.
صدوق، م.ب.ع. (1416ق). الخصال. دفتر انتشارات اسلامی.
کلینی، م.ب.ی. (1404ق). الکافی. دارالکتب الاسلامیة.
گلپایگانی، م.ر. (1413ق). الدر المنضود فی أحکام الحدود. انتشارات دارالقرآن الکریم.
مجلسی، م.ب.م.ت. (1404ق). مرآة العقول فی شرح أخبار آل الرسول. دارالکتب الاسلامیة.
مؤسسه دائرة‌المعارف فقه اسلامی. (بی‌تا). فقه اهل بیت علیهم السلام.
موسوعة آیت‌الله خوئی. (1418ق). التنقیح فی شرح المکاسب. مؤسسه إحیاء آثار الإمام الخوئی.

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics